Andrew pointed me towards Spirit Journal's list of the best spirits of 2005. In particular I was awed that #5 on the list is vintage 1995 Evan Williams Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey. I'm familiar with Evan Williams as the cheap swill alternative to Jack Daniels, so seeing this bottle so highly rated was amazing, totally leaving aside the fact that it retails for $25. Wow. Good luck finding it though. BevMo has the 1990 vintage.

Update: I can only find the bottle at one store: Wine Exchange. Drop a line if you locate it elsewhere.